« Back to Spotlights

Discover Italian Heritage in Dutchess County

Date Published: October 6, 2022

Culinary Institute of America Student in white uniform makes a pizza in front of a wood oven
The Culinary Institute of America, Hyde Park

Dutchess County is home to a diverse array of peoples and cultures. The region’s large cities and small villages were built by immigrants, including Dutch, German, Irish and Italian laborers. Explore Poughkeepsie’s Little Italy, Millbrook’s connection to a town in Lazio, a new San Gennaro Festival and lots of delicious Italian cuisine!

Events

Majed J. Nesheiwat Convention Center gray exterior with blue signage
Majed J. Nesheiwat Convention Center, Poughkeepsie

San Gennaro Festival

Sunday, October 9, 12-9 p.m. at Majed J. Nesheiwat Convention Center, Poughkeepsie

Experience this unique Italian cultural festival right in the heart of the Hudson Valley. San Gennaro is a feast celebrated to honor Saint Januarius, the patron saint of both Naples and Little Italy in New York City. Of course, Poughkeepsie has its own Little Italy and finally its own San Gennaro festival! Visit the Majed J. Nesheiwat Convention Center in Poughkeepsie on October 9 for traditional desserts, snacks and other specialties from local vendors. Enjoy Hudson Valley craft beer and wine plus live music and other entertainment. A major highlight will be the parade, a showcase of Italian heritage along Main Street. And, it’s a completely FREE event! For more information, click here.

Pizza in front of beer flight at Mill House Brewing Company
Mill House Brewing Company, Poughkeepsie

October Pop-Up: A Taste of Italy

Wednesdays in October at Mill House Brewing Company, Poughkeepsie

All month long, one of the region’s most prolific craft breweries pays homage to Italian-American cuisine. Mill House Brewing Company continues its creative and exciting pop-up series with A Taste of Italy. This specials menu puts a distinctly Dutchess spin on old world classics. A few standouts include the Tuscan pork ribs, calamari fra diavolo, and an eggplant parm pizza. They even take a stab at the iconic dish bistecca alla Fiorentina. Plus, score cannolis and tiramisu for dessert. Beer fans will surely discover new pairings beyond their wildest imaginations. For the full menu and other events, click here.

Aerial view of Poughkeepsie, many Victorian buildings and brick buildings with bridge crossing the Hudson River in back
Poughkeepsie

History - Poughkeepsie's Little Italy

Italian culture is an essential part of Poughkeepsie’s long, eclectic history. After emigrating Europe, many central and southern Italians traveled to New York and settled in Dutchess County. The Dutch were this county’s first European immigrants, but Irish, German and Italian laborers soon followed. Mediterranean men and women arrived in the late 1800s. Many of these 19th Century Italians worked on constructing the Poughkeepsie-Highland Railroad Bridge—now the Walkway Over the Hudson. In addition, they built schools, churches, and the first daycare center specifically for immigrant children. Pelton’s Mansion, an Italianate villa-style structure, housed the Poughkeepsie Day Nursery founded in 1859. 

White spire of Mt Carmel Church Poughkeepsie
Our Lady of Mt. Carmel Church, Poughkeepsie; Photo by Skip Pearlman

With a hand in so many community pillars, Italian families contributed greatly to the infrastructure and culture of Poughkeepsie. Find Little Italy in the Mount Carmel district of The Queen City, just a short walk from the stunning waterfront. According to the Historical Marker standing in Poughkeepsie’s Little Italy, over 4 million Italians arrived in America between 1896 and 1921. 

Aerial view of Poughkeepsie, many Victorian buildings and brick buildings
Poughkeepsie

Much of the city’s architecture reflects its Italian influence. Victorian-era Italianate buildings like the 1880s-constructed Cunneen-Hackett Arts Center give Poughkeepsie its trademark look. In 1928, several local organizations combined to form The Italian Center. 

La Deliziosa Italian Pastry Shop, Poughkeepsie

Searching for Italian sweets and treats? Skip the trip to New York City and visit this truly authentic bakery and pasticceria. For over 50 years years, La Deliziosa has generated incredible sfogliatelle, biscotti, cannoli, rum baba and specialty cakes. This is a Poughkeepsie Little Italy staple. Find them at 10 Mount Carmel Place. 

Aerial view of Poughkeepsie, many Victorian buildings and brick buildings with bridge crossing the Hudson River in back spring
Poughkeepsie

Rossi Rosticceria Deli, Poughkeepsie

Your visit to Dutchess County can’t be complete without trying one of the famous sandwiches at Rossi Rosticceria Deli. This nearly five-decade-old establishment creates mind-blowing panini with fresh focaccia, semolina, ciabatta or gluten-free rounds. The Number Four with pesto is a local favorite, featuring chicken cutlet, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers. (The Muffaletta and The Quattro Falso are also worth the try.) Rossi Alimentari can be found in Eastdale Village in Poughkeepsie for a modern deli and marketplace.

Aloy’s, Poughkeepsie

Hungry for pizza? Try Aloy’s renowned square thin-crust pizza, a popular meal since 1929. Pair with a trip to the Walkway Over the Hudson, and indulge in hearty Italian dishes after crossing the world’s longest pedestrian bridge.

Fall leaves on either side of road in Millbrook
Millbrook

History - Millbrook

Millbrook is another destination in Dutchess County with a rich Italian heritage. The 2017 documentary Il Villaggio di Millbrook explores the influx of immigrants to the Eastern Dutchess village. 

Lush park in Millbrook
Millbrook

Many of these immigrants arrived from Fondi, a city in the region of Lazio. Fondi was traditionally known as a citrus cultivator, halfway between the important trade centers Rome and Naples. Masons and stone workers began arriving in Dutchess in 1893, and they built many of Millbrook’s estates. Later, Italian boys got jobs as caddies at the local golf clubs. Their relationship with local “movers and shakers,” according to an article by Rural Intelligence, helped their assimilation process. Many of them became members, and eventually, golf champions. 

Barbaro exterior gray front with orange signage
Barbaro, Millbrook

Barbaro, Millbrook

Continuing the tradition of Italian heritage in Millbrook, Barbaro provides an excellent spot for a night out. Grab a seat in their atmospheric dining room, and enjoy a variety of staple dishes and modern twists. Dig into Neapolitan-style pizza fresh from a wood-fired Pavesi oven, gnocchi, risotto, grilled octopus, penne puttanesca and much more.

White Italian pastries
Pastries from The Culinary Institute of America, Hyde Park

Other Italian Eats

Il Figlio Enoteca, Fishkill

Il Figlio Enoteca offers unique Italian dishes in a stunning space. Their menu includes options for each course in the classic Italian dinner: aperitivo, primi, secondi, contorni and dulci. Past specials include creamy burrata with delicata squash, pecans and sage; ricotta cavatelli tossed with a six-hour veal bolognese, tomato and parmigiana reggiano; and a beautiful sautéed branzino with French lentils, roasted mushrooms, shallot and green herb salsa verde. To make a reservation, click here.

Italian style villa building with a rose garden in front on the campus of The Culinary Institute of America, Hyde Park
Ristorante Caterina de’ Medici, The Culinary Institute of America, Hyde Park

Ristorante Caterina de’ Medici at The Culinary Institute of America, Hyde Park

Dutchess County attracts foodies from all around the globe. A major draw is The Culinary Institute of America in Hyde Park, where visitors can sample mind-blowing cuisine prepared by the next generation of elite chefs. Inside a Tuscan-style villa sits Ristorante Caterina de’ Medici. Imported furniture, Venetian glass chandeliers and other decor set the scene for authentic regional meals. Dine on elegant dishes while overlooking the rose and herb garden and the majestic Hudson River. To make a reservation, click here.

Aroma Osteria Wappingers Falls
Aroma Osteria, Wappingers Falls

Aroma Osteria, Wappingers Falls

Experience a true celebration of foraging, farming and butchering, blending Italian techniques and principles with Hudson Valley ingredients. During the warmer months, dine al fresco on their lovely grapevine-lined patio. Of course, their rustic dining room brings warmth and charm to any occasion. Their expansive menu encourages repeat visits, as every course is represented with a dearth of decadent dishes. To explore their menu, click here.

« Back to Spotlights